Array

Even though the train platform heaters have started working (since November 1) the cold might still prevent you from wanting to wait there for any longer than you need to. These transit apps for Android can help you bide your time. Photo by Chicago Transit Authority.

Ed. note – This guest post was contributed by Nick Puczkowskyj, one of the producers of this year’s Cycle Messenger World Championship, and a daily Chicago Transit Authority rider. Nick offered to test transit apps for Android after seeing our review of iOS transit apps proceeding the iOS 6-Apple Maps debacle. 

For the commuter who needs to be in the know at all times, there are several apps available for Android phones. I went about testing three popular Chicago transit apps on my Samsung Galaxy S II. The apps were put through all of the same hurdles for my commute, which involves both bus and rail. Each app was used entirely for one day and then all three were used at once for one day. Every app was able to assist me with every part of my commute. However, some had stronger attributes than others.

My daily commute takes me from Logan Square to River North during pre-rush hour times. I start with a walk to the California Blue Line stop, get off at Clark/Lake, catch the 22 or 36 bus, and end near Chicago and Dearborn. Usually, I am at work by 6 AM and leave by 2:30 PM. It is imperative for me to catch the proper train as I cannot afford the luxury of frequency provided by rush hour. The apps required a high level of performance to suit my needs.

Transit Tracks

Download free version.

With its Modernist design and simplicity Transit Tracks is a straightforward, no nonsense app. This well organized and designed app contains everything you need to get from A to B. The features are well placed and setup in a thoughtful manner. Transit Tracks design is simple with the use of colors for rail lines and small accents only. Functionally and aesthetically, it is a sound application.

This is an app that is to the point. The homepage is setup for the for users to place and access their frequently routes. Users can swipe to different pages to view recent searches, nearby routes, favorite routes, and all listed routes, very handy. In the field the app performed above par against the rest. It developed the fewest glitches and smoothly operated even in poor signal areas.

Pros: easy to use, visually appealing, smooth operation

Cons: some navigation is required, too many filters

Array

Chicago Transit Tracker Lite

Download free version.

I don’t know why Chicago Transit Tracker Lite is the one of the most popular Chicago Transit apps from Google Play. Maybe its because I only used Tracker Lite, which is free. You can upgrade to Tracker Pro for $2.99, but why?

Being very familiar with the CTA I do not need to personalize any of my routes. This app can perform optimally with the tedious labeling of all legs of a commute. If you decide to not name each leg of your commute, the standard information given for each is poorly labeled and can be confusing. Furthermore, if a user needs to find times for a one-time route it must be added to the homepage.

Tracker Lite is an app that can get the job done without finesse. Ascetically, the interface is drab, not intuitive, and poorly organized. The program is somewhat convoluted when it comes to setup and use. One positive aspects, is all of your routes are laid out right in front of you on the homepage. There is no need to navigate to a separate screen to find arrival times. Finally, during my field test it performed adequately even in low signal areas and on subway platforms.

Pros: All routes info on one page

Cons: unintuitive, large advertisements, poor labels

Array

Ride Chicago

Download free version.

Ride Chicago is a truly a well designed application that contains exceptional form and function. Overall, the app performs well and meets the expectations of a transit app. The program’s setup and use is easy and intuitive.
Ride Chicago is a visually pleasing app. First off, the use of colors is well done. When in comes to displaying information to people colors present information in a systematic and thoughtful way. The layout of the app is well thought out, making navigation a breeze. Menu at the bottom, favorites, and nearby routes are all easy to use.

During test runs Ride Chicago’s mechanics performed well. The information was presented was direct. Not only did the app provide arrival time, but it also included bus numbers and distance from stop. This was a great feature when deciding whether to huff it or wait. Rail info was boldly displayed and included time of arrival. The nearby feature allowed users to locate a bus or rail route up to 3 miles away, impressive. Finally, the only fault found was spotty performance in low cell phone signal areas.

Pros: easy to use, colorful display, very detailed info

Cons: performance issues

Array

flattr this!

Tagged with:
 
  • Pingback: Find Android apps you don’t use to free up space – CNET (blog) | Android app update | Android review video

  • Pingback: Komunitas Android Indonesia

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Tom-Hagglund/1381355153 Tom Hagglund

    Thanks for reviewing these. I’ve just downloaded “Ride Chicago” on this review, and I’ll try it out for at least a few weeks on my Droid Bionic. I’m happy to see that today’s new bus line, the J14 Jeffrey Jump, appeared in the app, so the developers must be on top of things at the CTA.

    I live in Evanston, so I’m just as likely to use Metra or Pace as I am to use the CTA’s Purple Line, Red Line or bus lines. “Ride Chicago” is strictly for the CTA, so is not as useful to me as “Goroo” or “Google Maps” (for routing) and “TreKing” by Rez Mobile (paid, $4), all of which integrate all three RTA lines for me. (Google Maps seems a bit weaker on Pace routing than Goroo, however). I can use TreKing for routing, though it doesn’t give multiple alternatives like Goroo or Google Maps do. TreKing does have a “Quick Treks” feature that lists all the bus stops and routes near your location, even if you don’t know exactly where you are. I believe Metra times are supplied by Metra’s new (beta) Train Tracker GPS system. On the other hand, today’s new Jeffrey Jump doesn’t yet appear in TreKing, so they may not be entirely ahead of the curve on updates.

  • Al

    I can’t believe you didn’t review TreKing which has bus (CTA & Pace), L, and Metra estimated arrival times and many convenient features such as bookmarks, trip planning, and real-time maps. The developer is constantly updating and improving the app. There is a free version and a paid version for $4 which is definitely worth it. 4.6 rating with 915 ratings on Google Play.

  • http://www.facebook.com/donnie.wright.16 Donnie Wright

    i used to use the Treking app the one you pay for but now i switched to the goroo app the was produced by the RTA you just go to goroo.com on your phone an book mark it. Its really helpful! :)

    • http://www.stevevance.net/ Steven Vance

      The GoRoo site definitely has the broadest uses as it includes trip planning for all transit agencies, and can give directions on how to bike or drive to train stations. I feel it has some speed and usability limitations, though.

  • Mikeycantfail

    Transit Tracks is my favorite. I used Chicago Transit Tracker for a couple weeks but I despised the interface. Transit Tracks made it nice and easy to set my usual daily routes. The location tracking isn’t extremely accurate but its just workable enough

  • Pingback: Ride Chicago screenshot 1 of 2 | It's Android Time