Rob Bielaski, Steven, Mark de la Vergne, Eric Dumbaugh.
By coincidence both Steven and I recently appeared on two different panels about sustainable transportation within a few days of each other. Last Thursday I was part of the talk “Chicago Cycling: What’s Next?” at the Peggy Notebaert Nature Museum in conjunction with their “Bikes! The Green Revolution” exhibit. Monday Steven participated in the discussion “Safe Streets,” hosted by the Congress for the New Urbanism (CNU) at the Jefferson Tap, 325 N. Jefferson in the West Loop. The panelists talked about what makes streets safe, and discussed new developments in Chicago street design.
Based in Chicago and headed my former Milwaukee mayor John Norquist, CNU is a nonprofit that promotes walkable, bikeable, transit-friendly, mixed-use development. Joining Steven on the panel, which doubled as CNU’s monthly happy hour, were Eric Dumbaugh, an associate professor at Florida Atlantic University who has authored more than forty books about transportation and urban planning, and Mark de la Vergne, a project manager at Sam Schwartz Engineering who has worked on Chicago’s pedestrian plan, the Streets for Cycling 2020 plan, and will be involved with siting and outreach for the city’s upcoming bike sharing program.
Dumbaugh kicked off the talk by discussing his own unorthodox route into the urban planning field. “I’m not a normal engineer,” he said. “I was an English major. I got into engineering by walking around and seeing that most of our streets are designed stupidly.” He asserted that the streets that are the safest for pedestrians and cyclists are also the safest for motorists because of low speeds. “So why is it that we’re mobilizing all of society’s resources towards the elimination of traffic congestion? That’s what makes it so difficult to reclaim the streets for pedestrians.”
De la Vergne said that under the new administration at City Hall this is an exciting time to be working on sustainable transportation projects. “[Reopening the crosswalk at] Queen’s Landing was a huge statement that said, ‘This is where we’re going,’” he argued. Mayor Emanuel views better walking, biking and transit facilities as essential for improving Chicago’s economy, De la Vergne added. “He thinks the reason that Google is moving into the Merchandise Mart is because we’re building protected bike lanes.”
However, he noted that Chicago is behind other cities like New York, San Francisco and Philadelphia in creating innovative public spaces like “parklets” – parking spaces converted into green space – and pedestrian plazas, so he looks forward to seeing Chicago build these types of spaces in the future as part of the Make Way for People initiative. The city’s first parklet is slated to be built in a parking stall in front of Heritage Bicycles, 2959 N. Lincoln, hopefully later this summer.
Times Square pedestrian plaza in NYC. Photo by Gary Burke.
Steven, who has a keen interest in crash statistics, began by discussing the Illinois Department of Transportation’s stats for Chicago pedestrian crashes from 2005-2010. He noted that while pedestrian fatalities dropped during this period, possibly, fatalities for people nineteen and younger are up. “The really, really good news is that there have only been seven fatal pedestrian crashes in Chicago [based on published news reports] this year compared to 32 in 2010,” he said. He attributed the nationwide trend towards less pedestrian deaths to lower driving rates due to high gas prices, as well as increased transit and bicycle use.
He added that he’s glad the Chicago Department of Transportation (CDOT) recently came out with the Chicago Forward action agenda with the goal of eliminating all traffic deaths, although he acknowledged this target may be a bit unrealistic. De la Vergne responded, “If you’re setting a goal for fatalities, then zero needs to be the number,” eliciting chuckles from the audience. Steven noted that recently the city has been repainting marked crosswalks with high visibility zebra stripes and adding leading pedestrian interval traffic signals, which give walkers a head start over turning cars. “Those need to keep happening, at a faster rate.”
Moderator Rob Bielaski, an engineer at SPACECO, Inc., asked the panelists whether they thought “complete streets,” ones that accommodate all travel modes, are inherently dangerous. Dumbaugh said no, citing the example of the Dutch woonerf, a type of bike- and pedestrian-prioritized street where cars are permitted but must travel at slow speeds. But De la Vergne argued that Canal Street in the West Loop is an example of a street where too many different uses compete for space, including foot traffic, bikes, taxis, CTA buses and inter-city buses. “It’s a mess,” he said. “There shouldn’t be a bike lane on Canal. Clinton and Jefferson work much better for biking.”
A Dutch woonerf. Photo by La Citta Vita.
Steven responded, “I don’t think I’ve ever seen a complete street in Illinois.” He talked about Fletcher, the street where he lives, a narrow roadway with parking on both sides so that people have no choice but to drive slowly. “But there’s no ‘daylighting’ at the intersections – the parking goes all the way to the corner – so drivers can’t see pedestrians wanting to cross the street.” Dumbaugh argued that the term “complete street” may be inherently flawed because streets are never really completed. “Cities are not static. A street that’s complete now may not be in ten years.”
An audience member asked the panelists consider North Michigan Avenue to be a complete street. “No,” said Steven. “The sidewalks are too narrow.” He noted that pedestrians in a hurry sometimes walk in the street instead of the crowded sidewalks. De la Vergne argued that Michigan is a relatively successful street because of the high pedestrian, bus and cab volume but noted that transit “sucks” there because of congestion caused by private autos. “People shouldn’t be driving on Michigan.”
Michigan Avenue. Photo by Chadedward.
The conversation turned to ideas for improving State Street in the Loop. “You could see State Street becoming the Times Square of Chicago,” an attendee said, referring to the bustling New York City thoroughfare that was recently converted into a pedestrian plaza. De la Vergne responded that proposals to change the street design on State tend to meet resistance because of the failed pedestrian and bus mall that existed there in the Eighties and early Nineties. “State is kind of the third rail because the pedestrian mall didn’t work there.”
He contrasted Broadway and Clark in Edgewater and Andersonville as an example of the power that street design has over commerce. Since there are several Red Line stations adjacent to Broadway, it seems logical that there would be lots of foot traffic on that street. “But Broadway is a fast street with five lanes and nobody wants to walk on it,” he noted. As a result, there’s relatively little foot traffic on Broadway much of the street is dominated by auto-centric business, while two-lane Clark Street, a much more pleasant street to stroll on, has the thriving Andersonville pedestrian shopping district. “Everyone gets off the train and walks six blocks west to Clark,” he said.
Clark Street in Andersonville – photo by Irving Welski
All three panelists agreed on the importance of introducing “mobility education” that would teach students how to get around safely on foot and by bike, not just by driving, so that if they do drive they’ll know to operate responsibly around vulnerable road users. “In the Netherlands they take seven-year-olds to the ‘traffic garden’ where they use pedal cars and then they use bikes to get around a miniature city,” said Dumbaugh. Steven argued that tests for getting a drivers license are too easy and fail to weed out dangerous drivers. “After all, driving is what’s killing people, not walking or biking.”
De la Vergne said that when he does find himself behind the wheel he takes the safety of pedestrians and bicyclists very seriously. “My wife hates how I drive,” he said. “She’ll say, ‘Why are you driving so slow? There’s no one around!’ I just don’t want to kill anyone.”
Grid Chicago is a blog about sustainable transportation matters, projects and culture in Chicago and Illinois, by John Greenfield and Steven Vance since June 2011.
- Grid Chicago is parked. Come join us at Streetsblog Chicago!
- Over a Barrel: Why is City Hall barring Pedal Pub from operating?
- Redesigning North Avenue to better serve its purpose: shopping
- Today’s Headlines
- More from Marge: Alderman Laurino talks trails, bike sharing
- Next South Shore alderman must expand and protect existing transit
- Today’s Headlines
- Transition Plan: We’re making the move to Streetsblog Chicago!
- Construction update: Jackson buffered bike lane installed after 1.5 year delay
- Today’s Headlines
Western & Ashland BRT: Pros and Cons - This webpage summarizes the project details and describes the pros and cons for each of the 4 bus rapid transit scenarios
Crash Portal - Exploring bike crashes in the City of Chicago and elsewhere
Bike 2015 Plan Tracker - Monitoring the status of implementing the 153 strategies in the Bike 2015 Plan
Chicago Bike Map app - Carry a beautiful Chicago bike map on your iPhone, iPad, or iPod touch, along with numerous, helpful points of interest and resources
Contribute your photos to our Flickr group.