What keeps an El car from falling off the tracks on tight curves?


1977 derailment at Wabash and Lake – photo by Mark Llanuza

[This piece also ran in Time Out Chicago magazine.]

Q: Since I’ve switched from the straight-shot Red Line to the winding Brown Line, where you often feel like you’re about to ride right off the rails (and right into a nearby condo building), I’ve been wondering: At what speed would El trains hitting sharp curves come off the tracks?

A: A CTA train’s extremely low center of gravity and speed limits allow it to safely navigate the El’s many curves, according to spokeswoman Catherine Hosinski. As a train goes around a bend, like the tight S-curve on the Brown and Purple Lines just north of the Merchandise Mart, the car may seem to sway at an impossible angle, but most of the weight is still directed straight down, Hosinski says. This overcomes centrifugal force and keeps the wheels on the rails. “Also, a train’s speed through each curve is limited by the automated train control system,” she says. “This system enforces a maximum train speed that’s much lower than the speed that could cause a train to leave the rails.”

Despite Hosinski’s assurances that modern CTA cars are safe, over the years the CTA has suffered a number of train plunges (the Green Line in 1966 and ’72). A 1977 incident killed 11: Two trains collided at the Wabash Avenue and Lake Street curve, causing one train to fall off the tracks. “I’m not an apologist for the CTA, but over 10 billion people have ridden the system in its 120-year history and you’re talking about a few dozen fatalities,” says local transit authority Greg Borzo, author of The Chicago “L”, a history of the system [and a sponsor of this blog]. “That’s a pretty good safety record.” Soon after Borzo soothed our nerves, news broke that the CTA recently purchased hundreds of new 5000-series rail cars whose faulty craftsmanship could have led to derailments.

Published by

John Greenfield

John has lived in Chicago since 1989 and has worked a number of bicycle jobs, from messenger to mechanic to managing the Chicago Department of Transportation's bicycle parking program, arranging the installation of over 3,700 bike racks. He writes regularly for Time Out Chicago, Newcity, Momentum and Urban Velo magazines and works at Boulevard Bikes in Logan Square.

9 thoughts on “What keeps an El car from falling off the tracks on tight curves?”

    1. That would depend on many variables: the radius of the curve, how many people are in the car, weather conditions, etc., so it would be impossible for the CTA to provide a particular number. I did ask Catherine to provide the speed limit for a particular location, say the curve north of the Merchandise Mart, but she wasn’t able to get back to me by press time. I’ll keep an eye out for speed limit signs next time I’m riding this stretch.

  1. I think they are going to film a movie at the Wilson L-stop this summer with a staged train derailment. My Alderman said something to that effect at the last ward meeting. Aliens and/or gravity will get you every time.

      1.  I’ll try and find out. It could be a TV-movie. In other Wilson related news, the area has been crawling with surveyors the past few weeks making measurements for…something.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *